Real Time Analytics


 

Herman Cain’s 9-9-9 Plan Is Great in Theory, but…

I became a big admirer of Herman Cain back in the 1990s when he was a member of the National Commission on Economic Growth and Tax Reform (aka, the Kemp Commission).

I worked as a staffer for the Commission and was able to observe Mr. Cain in action over a period of several months. Suffice to say I like what I saw. Unlike many people in DC, he is not an empty suit.

That doesn’t means he’s perfect, as illustrated by his support for the TARP bailout, but he’s definitely on the right side of the dividing line between those who want freedom and those who want statism.

And his victory in the Florida straw poll is bringing lots of deserved attention to his campaign, leading several people to ask what I think about his economic agenda.

To get right to the point, it’s a very Reaganesque package of lower taxes and more freedom that can be divided into three parts.

1. His short-run plan, which he calls the “Immediate Boost,” is to slash personal and corporate tax rates to 25 percent and eliminate the capital gains tax.

2. His intermediate plan, which he calls the “Enhanced Plan,” eliminates the death tax and the payroll tax. But the most important part is the 9-9-9 plan, which is a 9 percent tax rate on personal income, a 9 percent tax rate on corporate income, and a 9 percent national sales tax.

3. His long-run agenda, which he calls the “Fair Tax,” is to eliminate all personal and corporate income taxes and adopt a national sales tax.

This all sounds great, but let me do a bit of nit-picking. I want to focus on part 2, particularly the 9-9-9 plan.

 

Read more at http://danieljmitchell.wordpress.com/2011/09/25/herman-cains-9-9-9-...

 

Tags: 9-9-9, Cain, Herman

Views: 66

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Given how divided this nation is politically, I don't expect us to have a major change in Congress at the next election.  Take Ohio, for example.  A poll released this week showed that the majority of likely Ohio voters disapprove of President Obama and disapprove of the job he is doing, and yet ... the President beat every Republican candidate currently running by at least a few percentage points.

 

This is just one example of the extreme uphill battle that we are facing in the coming election.  The voters distrust -- even dislike! -- the President and yet like every Republican candidate even less than the President.  Let's suppose that Mr. Cain does get elected.  If he does not get a fully-Republican-controlled House and filibuster-proof Republican-controlled Senate, then even if he gets started implementing his tax plan, it is unlikely that he will get it passed entirely, and that could leave us paying more taxes than ever before.

 

In addition, suppose that Mr. Cain is elected President and gets everything he needs in the legislative branch to pass his tax plan in its entirety.  If he does not at the same time oversee successful passage of a Constitutional amendment revoking Congress' power to tax incomes and embedding his tax plan in the Constitution, then some future Congress and President can undo completely what he has done and leave America in much worse shape.

Robert, that is exactly why we have a lot of work to do.  We can flip the Senate and give a filibuster proof majority to the Conservatives.  But it will require an engaged electorate and a committed grassroots movement.  Don't believe every poll you see.  It is unlikely that a disenchanted and unemployed constituency will re-elect Obama.  He is loosing ground on all fronts.  Even his strong supporters in 2008 are backing away from him now.

 

If we elect Cain he will do a good job, but we need to give him the support of Congress.  That is definitely doable.

RSS

Tea Party Nation is a social network

 






© 2013   Created by Judson Phillips.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service